The roof is Limited Common Property in all HOA, because if a new roof is required for the complex, then all roofs will get re-done at same time. I had similar problem many years ago with the former president of the HOA, I lived at, complaining about my dish and the size of my dog, eventually 1 day it lead to a physical confrontation, I stopped short of killing him (at my wife's begging me) the guy backed off complaining directly to me, but this didn't stop him from his letter writing campaign, (which got nowhere other than me receiving requests to take the dish down) then I got new neighbors on the townhouse next to me and they too started complaining about my dish, eventually, I had enough and sold my unit and bought into another place about 1/2 mile away, where I was able to put up a 1000.4 to go with my new 722k and point my original 500 dish to Canada Sats, now I have 2 dishes (I sub to both providers, wife is from Canada), I've had no issues with any neighbors or complaints from the HOA, in fact they even let me replace my brick and grass ground floor patio with concrete and allowed me to mount a proper pole to place my dishes on. I still see the old HOA Nazi around the neighborhood from time to time, but it's all calm, as I see him now as a man with nothing better to do in life than complain, it's just him and his old little dog that I found out had been attacked by a Shepherd, similar breed as my dog and this whole dish thing was just him trying to get revenge on the dog attack, but it wasn't my dog, this happened before we bought the first place. Anyhow I sold my unit for $80k more than I thought I could get for it, when the market was at it's peak, and glad I got out of there when I did. I'm so happy at my current place awesome people, But I also got smart, when there was a requirement for a new property management company to take over, Me and another owner who's got an HDTV and HAM antennas got together and we arranged for the new company to get the contract for this place, we went door to door and convinced a majority of owners here to approve of this new company's contract and we told them (Property Managers) not to mess with us 2 owners, otherwise we'll ensure their contract for this complex doesn't get renewed. Never had any issues. Wish you all the best of luck, sometimes these things happen for a reason.