Joe Torre is the worst manager in baseball when it comes to pitching decisions.
There is one reason and one reason only why the Dodger bullpen is the most over used bullpen in baseball, and it has nothing to do with the quality of their starters; it simply has to do with one man only, Joe Torre. I cannot tell you how many times he pulled a starter out of a game when that starter was dominating the game, and that starter could have easily gone at least one more inning.
Today is just another example of Torre's stupid managing. Kershaw was dominating the Cards for 8 innings. Torre pulled him out in the 9th to bring in Broxton only because Broxton is the closer. Why in the hell does the closer always have to close? A good opportunity to save the bullpen, yet again, was just ruined by another stupid Torre move.
Well needless to say, Broxton ended up blowing the save with 2 broken bat singles and a wild pitch after 2 outs. Now the game is going extra innings and guess what? Yep, they are going to have to overuse their bullpen again. A game in which the entire bullpen could have taken the day off is no longer the case.
All Torre had to was leave Kershaw in. The worst he could have done is allowed them to tie it (which happened anyway). At least they would have had one less inning in which the bullpen was used. Even if Kershaw gave up more than one run, the Cards would have won the game and the bullpen would still not have been used.