Dustin is old school and I like his gritty play. His first few years have been good and one year has been really good (not MVP quality IMO, but good). I can honestly say that he is not even close to Utley in performance. If given the choice between these two at 2nd, I would guess that most managers would easily pick Utley. Utley has also been more consistent for much longer, as well as being a much more productive power hitter and a non power position.Yes it was hyperbole on my part only to point out someones hypocrisy. (With Youk and Tek)
But there is no way someone is going to tell me that Utley is better than Pedroia. I watch them both almost every day, it is close but I will take Dustin.