Well Gamefly has been good for me the past 7+ years and nearly 180 games I've received from them. And I think what helped them is that I've always been a big game renter and without any good alternatives GF was all there was. Finally, getting 15% off new games (rent it ASAP, then keep it) was quite nice as well and led to a number of good purchases. But now with games being so cheap with sales on Steam and Humble Bundles and various freebies from XBL and PSN+ there's literally never a time when a new game isn't easily and cheaply accessible. And my Steam Library is up to so many games, and doesn't even count all the games that have not been redeemed. I literally think I have more games in my possession than I could reasonably beat within my lifetime (given my schedule), which is cool and scary when you think about it. The Order will likely be my last game from GF for the foreseeable future.