I guess everyone has caught onto my bias by now.
I saw right through it.....
I guess everyone has caught onto my bias by now.
Why does the media fawn over this guy before he has had any postseason success?
Warren Moon had major success already in the CFL, so there was a good basis for high expectations. As I remember, Moon always put up big numbers too. I put that generation of Houston Oilers in the same category as the Air Coryell San Diego Chargers. All offense, zero defense. Like Dan Fouts, Moon is in the NFL Hall of Fame.I remember Warren Moon also got some major media fawning when his Oilers, also a talented offensive team, always choked in the playoffs.
And Ben was also put into an ideal situation with the Steelers during his rookie Super Bowl run. Winning a Super Bowl doesn't make him a top 4 QB in this league. Many would argue that Dan Marino was one of the best and he never won the big salami.
It took Peyton years to win a playoff game, he eventually did. Romo will too sooner or later.
It doesn't hurt. In my book he is in the top four. Winning as many starts as he has counts big in my ratings. He very rarely is the reason for the Steelers losing, that counts too. No personal bias here, I just call them as I see them. The boy is a winner, plain and simple. He does exactly what the Steelers (and for that matter, any team) need to win. Too many QB's try to do too much and cost their teams games. Detroit's Kitna is an example of this. (Of course when you play for the Lions....). Matt Ryan displayed this ability last Sunday, he didn't try to win the game, and didn't make any mistakes that cost them the game. Same for Aaron Rogers.
I'd put Romo ahead of Ben and Palmer. Palmer IMO is overrated. Ben is just a big ox.
A big OX ??
Being Big makes you a winner at QB in the NFL ?
If I recall, he won like 16 of his first 20 games, also won a SB ....
That alone is something NONE of the guy's you mentioned have done.
Yes, he's playing with a good team and that surely helps, but are you telling me that he's the only one that came in with a winning team ?
That is the problem with rating college QB's, a lot of the ones that make it to the NFL, would do much better if they were drafted by a different team, before they are ran into the ground playing for a losing team. Some of these guys are not as bad as they appear.
Aaron Rogers may be a prime example, personally, I think he'll do fine, but , had he went with say the Lions or another perrenial losing team, he would have been lost in the NFL as another bust of a high profile QB.
Jimbo
Good post Jimbo. To prove your point - as good as Peyton and Eli are, they're dad Archie was even better! But he was destined for mediocrity by playing with the Saints (who were truly the Aints in Archie's day). As a player, he deserved better, but I imagine he's getting some sweet revenge with two of his boys winning Superbowls back to back.
And we all know HDMM hates Big Ben because.
Big Jen will meet Big Shaun Rogers Sunday! I can't feakin wait! How's that O-Line this year Stoolers? You guys will be wishing you didn't get rid of Alan Faneca come Sunday night.
Here we go Brownies, here we go! Woof WOOF!!!!!
So.... how about Joseph Addai/Adrian Peterson matchup?
San Diego @ Denver. I wonder if Denver is as good as they looked against the Raiders. Will the Bolts light up the Denver secondary with no Champ Bailey and no John Lynch? Can the Bolts get to Jay Cutler without Merriman? Will the revamped Denver defense now be able to stop the run? After all the preseason hype, will the Bolts go to 0-2?Here are my NFL matchups I'm most looking forward to this weekend:
1) Cleveland vs. Pittsburgh (I'll be attending in person)
2) Philadelphia @ Dallas
3) New England @ New York Jets
4) Indianapolis @ Minnesota