I have 2 HWS. For me, this is a perfect setup. However, some people do not want to go to a different room to change, edit, delete tuners, when there is an option to do it from one location(any tv location). That was the benefit of the SJ, and one of the biggest reasons Dish offered that, rather than just stick with 2 hoppers. Different users have different preferences, and you and I have similar preferences, but there was a 2 week long debate about the SJ integration when it first came out. Half the crowd loved full integration and begged for the 2 hopper option to be, and others hated having integration, and beg to keep them separate. So depending on his preference of use and viewing habits, the SJ may be the better option for him. Has nothing to do with being argumentative, just with preference. Finally Dish gives the option for ones home viewing preference, and now we are arguing that these options are not a good thing. Netflix may not be his issue, but one single room continuity could be a big deal.