let's talk practical
A year ago, I saw a 1080P demo on a 72"(?) TV at Fry's.
It came with its own hard drive, to show you what it could do.
Honest to #$&!, you'd have though you were standing at a big picture window and looking out!
I don't know when I've been so moved by an actual view of nature!
Words could not do justice to the image.
It took my entire view and transported me to wherever the video was recorded.
I wonder if that's what drugs are like?
It sure was addictive!
Back to Reality:
All last year, I was angling for a good deal on a
Syntax 542 (42" LCD)
At a day-after-Xmas-sale, I got one for $799 at MicroCenter.
I knew it had an LCD panel that was 1366 x 768, but after viewing it in stores, I felt it was quite good.
At the time, pricing ranged from $1000 to $1200, if you shopped
well.
1080p LCD sets were becoming available, but only from 3rd tier suppliers for prices under $2000
Price Club had one for around $1500 , but it wasn't equipped the way I wanted (no tuner).
In Los Angeles, off-the-air gives 45 digital channels, and I wasn't about to ignore those free choices!
From an 8..10 foot viewing distance, I can't tell the difference between network 1080i, and 720p.
I will assume my scaler and panel limit my view quality, but it's -
such- a boost over 480 analog !
Watch outdoor scenes on
CSI Miami some time, on a direct HiDef local station, if you want a rush.
I can't imagine waiting to get a real 1080p.
Not for my set-size and viewing distance.
Actually, there's a local LA channel producing some beautiful in-studio Mexican programming in digital 480i that is just outstanding!
Getting to the Point:
So, what's the point?
Maybe, that having a decent bit rate is more important than the actual resolution.
At least, for many of today's TV sets.
And then, there's always the question of the quality of the down-converter used to achieve these less-than-spec video formats.