No, you are ignoring what HAS ALREADY happened. People in outside of Fairfield cty, CT had full access to YES HD(whatever Directv was covering) with the sports pak, last year. This year , unless you live in Fairfield cty, regardless if you have the sports pak, those same people, no longer have full access to YES HD anymore, yet no access rules have changed, which would bar them from being allowed to receive it. That has been what this discussion has been mainly about and why it is occuring.
In response to your edit...
But they aren't receiving the full compliment of games, like they were last year. Just because a few of the games show up on the same channel, that EVERY game did(that directv covered) last year, doesn't mean they are receiving what they did last year. Come on.