Thanks for posting this and confirming I'm far from ready for the next gen console. In no particular order, here's what my backlog now looks like (games I have already, via Plus or otherwise, are starred):
The Last of Us
Vanquish*
LEGO Marvel Super Heroes
Portal 2
Red Dead Redemption
Fallout New Vegas
Tomb Raider*
Limbo*
Skyrim
Saints Row III*
XCOM: Enemy Unknown*
Rayman Legends
Dragon Age Origins
South Park: The Stick of Truth
Far Cry 3
Ni No Kuni
And that's of course only games available on the PS3. (I thought that was dumb that the IGN list didn't usually state the platform for games that were exclusive. Some like Mario and Halo were obvious, of course, but there were a few others I never heard of before.)
I agree that they should have listed the platforms each game is available on next to the year of release. Just from the small section of the games you picked I have a few i want to play myself. Red Dead Redemption and Fallout 3/New Vegas are near the top of my priority list. I'd like to play Ni No Kuni at some point too but I'm kind of waiting for PS+ on that one. I have also started LEGO Marvel, Tomb Raider, Skyrim, Rayman Legends, Dragon Age Origins, and Far Cry 3 and I intend to finish all of them at some point.
I used to have a rule where I wouldn't start a new game until I finished whatever I was currently playing. Lately I have so many games and not enough time to play them so I tend to jump around a bit more depending on what I'm in the mood for at the time. Until typing out that list of games I've recently started just from your list alone I didn't realize just how many games I'm currently working on. I just have too many games I want to play and not enough time to play them. I may need to start locking myself into a single game until I'm finished with it again.