Caller ID has never worked on any of my Hoppers.
I have never called Dish or Verizon Wireless to troubleshoot the problem.
Doesn't matter which cell phone rings, no caller ID.
You can't get caller ID on a cell phone aside from contacts listed, there are some apps that let you know city/county type thing but thats about it. Shame they won't track landlines to cell phones as regular caller ID does as it would be rather useful.
But as noted too you can't get caller ID thru the hoppers from a cell phone, they just don't match up in anyway.