Replacing everything sucks if you are in house and your materials are paid for.
Worse if you are a sub (like me) and you flip the bill for that too.
I say if you are in house, replace it if it doesn't take too long.
You didn't pay for, just do it.
Otherwise, make a judgement call.
I take a lot of pride in my work, but sometimes, I can't afford to.
Recently, I failed a QC that either I fixed it or got charged back the job.
I told to charge me back.
I went there just to ad a receiver.
If I was to fix everthing there, I would have had to done everything including reburying the pole and rewiring the hole house.
Would have taken 2-3 hours and 2-3x the money in materials than the job paid.
Sorry, but forget it.
We should have an option to send a supervisor out to the job to inspect for re installation and get paid for it instead of being expected to do it for free.