MLB Award Predictions

Ok, then what's the point of this award? I'm not trying to argue, with you Ramy or anyone else, I just don't see the point of this award.

It's like an ESPY award then, and call it such. Don't base it on something and not go by that when it comes to handing out the hardware.


Here you go MLB, here's a bag to put all your BS in.

I agree.
 
A agree with Tracy getting the award, but don't agree that Scioscia should have won. I would have given it to Ron Gardenhire. The Angels had a very talented team in the weakest division on all of baseball, and they would have won despite Scioscia. The Twins came from behind to win their division with a team that had a lot less talent in a more competitive division.

1. The Angels had to overcome the tragic death of Nick Adenhart

2. The Twins didn't do much until September. I wouldn't name Gardenhier Manager of the Year based on one good month.
 
1. The Angels had to overcome the tragic death of Nick Adenhart
Should that be a factor? I think a minor one. But, the whole team had to bond together and families usually do that even without a leader.
2. The Twins didn't do much until September. I wouldn't name Gardenhier Manager of the Year based on one good month.
You don't win a division on one month. And to excel in the toughest month of all does require good leadership.
 
Technically the Tigers did make the playoffs, albeit a 1 game against the Twins.

Basically, if that's the case then what's the point? If all the award votes are popularity contests then don't call then different awards.


Joe Mauer, hey sorry you didn't win MVP this year, but here's a GG for ya, WTF?

Technically, they didn't. The one game "playoff" was part of the regular season.
 
The pot head wins the NL Cy Young for the second straight year. I would bet that Wainwright or Carpenter would have beat him if they were not on the same team.
 
The pot head wins the NL Cy Young for the second straight year. I would bet that Wainwright or Carpenter would have beat him if they were not on the same team.

This dude is living in the wrong era, that's for sure. Right city, wrong era.

custom_1258737279048_lincecum.jpg
 
Here's your voting break down :

Tim Lincecum 11 12 9 100

Chris Carpenter 9 14 7 94

Adam Wainwright 12 5 15 90

Wainwright had 1 more First place vote, but 10 less over all fwiw.
And I would be willing to bet if these two were not on the same team, then Wainwright would have won
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 0, Members: 0, Guests: 0)

Who Read This Thread (Total Members: 1)

Latest posts

Top