Just pointing
I'm just pointing out that you are using a Monster promo as fact. I don't buy Monster for the reason I stated: It's mark up is 300%. If someone wants to pay that kind of mark up that is up to them. You are correct that taking 8 conductor bell & put RJ45 connectors on it and it isn't cat 5. The reason is that bell wire isn't twisted pairs that cancels out noise. That's why I would never suggest one do that. That has nothing to do with the fact that 2 cables w/ the same AWG are going to do the same thing: that's engineering 101.
Congratulations on posting a link to where a bunch of unqualified, uneducated (in regards to the technology) are disputing the validity of claims made by many cable manufacturers.
1080i, while much larger than 480p in the volume of data sent from component to TV, it's certainly not going to stop there. Even HD content is still shot at 24FPS. However, for gamers, a video game can be put out in higher resolutions than 1080P with a refresh rate of 120hz and 16 bit color. The average HDMI cable would not be able to handle that much throughput without collisions, reflections and other losses/corruption of data. That is where the GBPS rating comes into play. The more Gigabits of data a cable can pass per second, the better your end result (TV pic and audio) will be.
You can take 8-conductor bell wire and put RJ45 connectors on it, but that won't make it a cat5 or cat6 cable.
If you don't like Monster, then there are other certified cables out there. There's a few companies that certify HDMI cables, just look for the cables that have have been independently tested and you'll have less problems. Although there isn't any broadcast content that is pushing 1080x1920x120hz, cables that can push that level of data will have no problem passing a Dishnet or DirecTV receiver's signal.
I'm just pointing out that you are using a Monster promo as fact. I don't buy Monster for the reason I stated: It's mark up is 300%. If someone wants to pay that kind of mark up that is up to them. You are correct that taking 8 conductor bell & put RJ45 connectors on it and it isn't cat 5. The reason is that bell wire isn't twisted pairs that cancels out noise. That's why I would never suggest one do that. That has nothing to do with the fact that 2 cables w/ the same AWG are going to do the same thing: that's engineering 101.