FAIR WARNING TO THOSE ADVERSE TO LONG, EXPLANATORY POSTS...YOU MAY WANT TO JUST SKIP THIS......But since I spent a half hour trying to compose this, I'm going to post it anyway...in spite of the fact that some have said it just as eloquently, in fewer paragraphs.
chaotic said:
When someone's 1st post of VOOM is positive it's "Welcome To VOOM!"
When someone's 1st post of VOOM is negative it's "Troll Alert!"
...I fully agree with you
chaotic, but for any newbies on board[/B], I have to post this disclaimer...and it's NOT aimed at you any of the other "older hands" who follow your post. Nor is it aimed at the original poster...
I feel you suspect you were both just stating your positions and opinions, and both of you are entitled to to that.
My comment is more directed to newcomers to this board, and perhaps "older hands" who have experienced the non-disputed (at least by me) strain of trying to have patience...it's beginning to wear on everyone's nerves.
I beseech us all, myself included...think before you type....
"Check prior posts before forming opnions BEFORE deciding "troll" or "cheerleader", also take into account how many posts in total show in their profile, and over what period of time.
Beyond that, try to pay attention to where they post currently (this can be distorted by the fact that I believe only 20 pages of posts (for the way I'm set up, with 25 posts per page or a total of 500 current posts) show as being currently when you search all posts by an individual;
If they have a high amount of posts, and most of the posts are on this forum in the last 90 days or so, it could be either...in which case it would be necessary to visit all the other forums, and use the option "show all posts since the beginning" to check back beyond the 500 post limit to see where they posted previously on other forums and study prior posts in order to form your own opinions."
This exercise can be very telling in the case of Trolls, as sometimes all their current posts are in this forum, while prior posts may be in forums they may more closely align with. If you see references in current posts that relate to other sites...give those a quick gander, too.
But, most of all, try to take note of subtle undercurrents in the posts you read, and
can see on this forum, even without having to review every post on this whole site back to the time the posters became registered...they are very important in determining the current agendas of the posters...
If what you find is primarily negative and the majority of their posts are ONLY on this site...especially recently...it may well be a Troll. But look at the content too, someone who criticizes VoOm for whatever reason, is not necessarily a Troll. He or she may simply be someone who has a good grasp of the technicalities that figure into the current situation, and is trying to convey that. On the other hand, repeated negativity, (without a long prior history of supportive or at least, constructive comments)...
may very likely be a Troll.
If there are
few prior posts to go on, it
may be a newbie who has simply lost patience OR, it may be a Troll.
I personally, don't find new posters
that hard to believe, because I was there once and cancelled. I am being tested again in re-subscribing, but please, don't just write new posters off even if they are negative in the beginning.
If you have suggestions to give, please do so. If you support their opinions without recourse, do that too...but base your position on either experience
or facts that can be substantiated in some form. Then everyone can have a better shot at forming a reasoned opinion as to the best choice for them.
All that blah, blah, blah (if you read through it) is just
my personal opinion on what I consider some common sense,
lacking any personal technical certainty of agendas of most posters...regarding the current situation in a very tense time...It's just what has helped me decide to whose opinions to trust since my first VoOm experience nearly 18 months ago...and it's based on what I've learned since...from posters here...whether they were agreeing at the time with my position or not.