Well, I have decided to go back to YTTV.
Checking my points’ balance on my PNC Credit Card convinced me to do it, have over 800,000 points, each $250 Google Play Card is a tad over 100,000 points.
So I will get about 6 of them, which will easily take care of a year+ of YTTV and whatever ST will cost, then I will let the points build up again.
In comparison, you can get other stuff with the points, for example I saw the Nintendo Switch OLED version, which is $339 at the stores, but it was over 400,000 points, so the Gift Cards are a better bargain.