Here is what we got...
Chet K called into the office first and spoke with Ernie and got some information for his father, and asked questions about Club Dish and using the Dishstore rebate.
The father called in and left a message for one of my sales reps named Ernie.
Ernie called Chet K's father back and closed the sale.
I listened to all the calls, and when the actual customer called in and spoke with Ernie there was no discussion about what the actual rebate amount would be. It was pretty much here is the club Dish card number from my son, and what paperwork is required for the rebate such as first months bill.
When Chet K Origionally called in and spoke to Ernie, he did ask if he could combine it with Club Dish and was told the rebate would be $25 less, and that the amount of the rebate is dependant of what father signed up with.
It clearly says on the rebate form and website what rebate this customer would be receiving. My rep did say $25 less, instead of $25, So I will give this customer the benifit of the doubt and pay the additional $25 on Monday which will make the total rebate $50.
I think this is a fair resolution, I'll be glad to post the recordings (Minus personal information) if both Chet K and his father requests it.