And what color did antennaweb say those 44 miles out stations were?
A couple of rules-of-thumb for antennaweb. First, it is conservative and based on outdoor antenna reception. If you install the antenna configuration they recommend for a given channel, mostly likely you will get it. Second, for an attic install, jump the color code up at least one level and you have a fair to good chance of receiving the signal. Finally, unless your channels are pumping out at 500 to 1,000 kw, with an attic antenna you need a good pre-amp (e.g., CM 7775). Also, attic antennas don't work if you have a steel roof.