I can see both points to this story, the problem was the check by phone payment causing issues with the system and putting the account in soft disconnect statis.
I can sympasize with your situation on this. The difference between you and the typical customer who goes into Non-pay disconnect is that you have the money to pay the bill.
But heres something you should consider....
The way your being treated is a direct result of your payment history. As a Dish Network dealer I deal with customers who don't pay their bills every day. It creates a big problem for everyone, first of all the dealer will either get charged back or will loose his residual on your account. The next time you call in and need service, your payment history is going to depend on how fast I service your account and if I even decide to service it at all.
For example, I got a commercial MDU account down by Cleveland Ohio. Its on one of those summer party islands and the owner rents out the condos on the island for several hunderd dollars per week. The programming bill for this property is about $1200/mo and when he pays his bill I get 15% of that as a residual payment. This guy only pays his bill twice per year, the week before Memorial Day Weekend, and a week before Labor Day weekend. I get paid my residual for the month of June, and then get it charged back again in July, and the residual pays again in October and charged back in November.
Needless to say this guy has got lots of issues with trees on the island, and he needs me to send out 2 of my installers to move several of the Dishes. I told him there is going to be a charge to have us come out where his argument is that it should be FREE since he is a paying customer. If he paid his bill, I make over $1500/yr on his account, since he has a problem paying his bill ontime I do not make that residual so refuse to go out and service the account.
Last I heard from him he wants me to re-imburse him for the service calls since he had to pay someone else to fix it. Pay your bill and I'll fix your stuff for FREE!
But the same thing holds true when you call customer service, they look at your payment history and they just don't believe that you'll pay. The DISH Network CSR's see so many accounts that are always in disconnect, they think your just like everyone else who doesn't pay their bill ontime and are always fighting a Non-Pay Disconnect.
As a stastic that I see, about 90% of new customers who signed up in the last 12 months who go Non-Pay Disconnect do not have the money to reconnect. Out of the 10% who do reconnect, 75% of those people will go Non-Pay disconnect again in the next 6 months.
After 1 year, I would guesstimate that 20-50% of all Non-Pay disconnects do not restart service!