Who will win? HD DVD or Blu-ray?

Who will win? HD DVD or Blu-ray?

  • HD DVD will win!

    Votes: 127 35.2%
  • Blu-ray Disc will win!

    Votes: 115 31.9%
  • Both formats will coexist for a long time.

    Votes: 70 19.4%
  • I don't know.

    Votes: 49 13.6%

  • Total voters
    361
I really think it will be a long battle before we know which one will win.
We can't really compare them to the Betamax. Betamax can only play movie and record TV programs while both Blu-ray and HD-DVD are not just for playing movies.
They're both can be used to store data on the PC side and for Gaming console on PS3.

HD-DVD has the lead on the lower price and out early on the market.
(But two months ahead is not really a big deal I wonder how many got sold so far)

Blu-Ray is a lot more expensive than HD-DVD but might win on the PC side. Since it can hold more Data and if PS3 becomes popular that might push blu-ray into the lead.

I think the recorder will decide the fate of these two formats. Right now, who would want another player. Poeple just want to be able to record HD TV shows.
Why buy a player now when the recorder is just around the corner.

Just my two Cents
 
HD-DVD and Betaray already obselete

Microsoft wants to dominate the MEDIA CENTER world with VISTA systems networked with HDD RAID or SATA ARRAY with PVR function combined with broadband pipeline for dowloading HD-VOD movies ....

This approach is backed by Mark Cuban of HDnet fame and Rupert Murdoch of DTV , BskyB and FOX news fame ...

They envision the world where theatrical movies will be available for 2 viewing licence download with option for permanent archive after movie is finished it's run in the theatres...

So the theatres owners will have to change there biz model to 4K digital projectors with some big theaters sporting 2 for James Cameron and Lucas push for 4K ultimate 3D blockbusters which they will soon be using for there next films.

The future's so bright I got to wear shades...

UPDATE :

Adult industry turns technology corner
GARY GENTILE

Associated Press

Los Angeles — Hollywood has been tiptoeing its way toward letting consumers buy a movie online, burn it onto a DVD and watch it on a living-room TV.

While the studios hesitate, the adult film industry is taking the leap.

Starting Monday, Vivid Entertainment says it will sell its adult films through the online movie service CinemaNow, allowing buyers to burn DVDs that will play on any screen, not just a computer.

It's another first for adult film companies that pioneered the home video market and rushed to the Internet when Hollywood studios still saw it as a threat.

“Leave it to the porn industry once again to take the lead on this stuff,” said Michael Greeson, founder of The Diffusion Group, a consumer electronics think tank in Plano, Tex.

“The rest of Hollywood stands back and watches and lets the pornography industry work out all the bugs,” he said.

There are business and technology factors that make it easier for adult film companies to embrace new technology faster than traditional media.

On the business side, Hollywood makes more money offering films on DVDs than in theatres. As a result, studios are hesitant to anger large retailers such as Wal-Mart Stores Inc. and Blockbuster by selling DVD-ready downloads directly to consumers.

Recently, most of the big studios have started selling films over the Web, including on CinemaNow, which is partly owned by the film studio Lions Gate Entertainment Corp., Microsoft Corp., Cisco Systems Inc. and Blockbuster Inc. Consumers can burn a backup DVD, but it can only be played by a computer, not a DVD player.

The adult film industry doesn't face the same business challenges.

“We don't have to divvy up the pie,” said Bill Asher, co-chairman and co-owner of Vivid Entertainment, the largest distributor of adult entertainment. “We sell in smaller stores, mainstream chains, but no one dominant component where we're going to get that phone call.”

There are also technical issues for Hollywood to resolve.

To prevent piracy, studios now use what's known as the “content scrambling system,” or CSS, to keep consumers from copying DVDs and sending the files around the Internet.

The system, which is easily circumvented, is built into every DVD player to block the playing of movies on discs burned by a computer.

That obstacle has been overcome in the design of high-definition DVDs, which are just now becoming available.

Both rival high-def brands, HD DVD and Blu-ray, use new protection schemes that allow DVDs burned in a computer to play on a DVD player. But it will be years before new players that accommodate those discs replace older models.

The studios say they are preparing to allow the online burning of DVDs for playing on TVs once the new high-definition players become widely adopted.

Vivid says its downloads, which will cost $19.95, do not use CSS. Instead, online retailer CinemaNow is using an alternate, proprietary system that it says will protect the adult movies by preventing the burned DVD from being copied to other discs.

“They built a better mousetrap,” Asher said of CinemaNow.

Despite the challenges, mainstream studios are taking some risks and inching toward downloadable DVDs.

Both Warner Bros. and Universal Studios have launched hybrid programs overseas in which consumers who download films also get a DVD in the mail.

But the real goal, analysts say, is to pipe major Hollywood movies and TV shows over the Internet directly to TV sets, bypassing DVDs altogether.

“How about I just turn my set on and press 'go,”' Mr. Greeson said. “That's the holy grail.”

Hollywood is moving slowly in that direction but must first devise ways to placate retailers, broadcast affiliate partners, movie theatres and others with bottom lines threatened by the move.

“The more they champion Internet distribution directly to the consumer, the more it seems they're turning their back on their old media partners, which they can't afford to do,” Mr. Greeson said.

So yet again, unencumbered by such business roadblocks, the adult film industry could lead the way.

“The vanguard here is porn,” Mr. Greeson said. “They made a tremendous amount of money on the Web, but they know they can make more if they get to the living room.”



Perhaps all those new fangled HD-DVD / Betaray will be used as archivers :)


And so it begins ....
 
Last edited:
T2k said:
You couldn't be more wrong on this... how can you say this?

You could be more WRONG

Why?

Because:

1. I dont know anyone that doesnt already own a DVD player which can be used in the interim until the majority of titles are made into HD DVD. Infact I would bet the these high end consumers already own upconverting players like the Oppo or the LP2. ANd if they dont their HDTV's probably already upconvert the material. :rolleyes:

and

2. No one is going to want to watch DVD after owning an HD DVD Player. Raise your hand HD DVD player owners if you are planning more DVD purchases. My guess is there will be a steady flow of DVD's back to blockbuster for credits toward HD DVD purchases and increased ebay DVD sales. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:

Consumer reports on HD DVD

CNET Report on HDMI Errors with the Toshiba HD-A1

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 0, Members: 0, Guests: 0)

Who Read This Thread (Total Members: 1)