I've only ever played the episodes of a Telltale game within a week's time. And yes, sometimes the contradictions I spot are much more subtle than relating to a major decision like beating someone up.
However, my biggest gripe with Telltale games are the length, part of which is tied to the dumbing down of puzzles. But even when I replayed season 1 of TWD and knew what to do, it seemed most episodes (except the final one) were in the 2 to 2.5-hour range. Since The Wolf Among Us, I don't think I've seen an individual episode of a Telltale game go more than 90 minutes, and lately the games I've played have been in the 60-75 minute range. Michonne was especially disappointing in the regard. How long are the Batman episodes?