A few months ago if someone at D* said we'd give you 50 new HD channels but you'd have to pay $4.99/month for them I bet the vast majority would be jumping all over that deal. I don't see what the big deal is, $4.99/month if you want the HD only channels if not don't pay it or go to E* where you'd still be paying more for their HD package. This stuff ain't free folks, someone's got to pay for it.