I took this post off of a different forum that I peruse each day....the TIVO HD PVR forum.
The writer of the post...pasted in below is a "heavy hitter" with over 7500 posts on that site....the thread that he is writing about is the possibility of VOOM making an "imprint" on the HD world.
Kind of "forcing" D and E to add more HD....cuz VOOM is coming on strong according to one writer....but then he ended his post by saying that even if VOOM fails...some one will "buy" them. Grin.
Here is the post...unedited...name withheld....
================================================
Why would DTV want a bunch of themed HDnet-like wannabe channels?
What exactly is really out there in HD that might be worth carrying right now that DirecTV doesn't already have?
* HBO HDTV East
HBO HDTV West
* Showtime HD East
Showtime HD West
* HDNet
* HDNet Movies
iNDEMAND HD
iNDEMAND HD 2
The Movie Channel HD
Starz! HD East
Starz! HD West
* Discovery HD Theater
* CBSHD East (WCBS-NY)
* CBSHD West (KCBS-LA)
* ESPN HD
Cinemax HDTV East
Cinemax HDTV West
MSG Network HDTV
Fox Sports Net HDTV
Bravo HD+
* Spice HD
Announced
A&E HD
The History Channel HD
* FOX HD East
* FOX HD West
TNT-HD
* Now carried by DirecTV (or announced)
HBO HD and Showtime HD can't even manage anything close to 24-hour HD broadcasting, resorting to upconverts a substantial amount of the time.
Are Cinemax, Starz and The Movie Channel any different? Of them all, I'd like to see Starz HD; it seems it has the possibility to offer the most additional content to the mix of existing channels. Does it live up to that possibility? I dunno. Will it eventually? I'd think so.
Of channels that don't exist, there could be some interest in a Sundance HD channel, perhaps a Science Fiction HD channel, maybe even a TVLand HD channel.
What would be cool? A public access HD channel.
What is inevitable that is going to make us all collectively groan? An HD shopping channel.
Right now I think the majority of what we don't have is just "more of the same" of what we do have and while sure it'd be nice to have a little more, I think we'd be left wanting if we got what's available now.
This is a time of transition; now we need programmers to catch up a bit and actually offer more HD.
Now Voom...
"Voom HDTV Exclusives: 21 amazing channels!"
OK, where? Only 12 are listed:
Rave HD
Rush HD
HDNews
Ultra HD
Monsters HD
WorldSPORT HD
Epics HD
Treasure HD
Gallery HD
MOOV HD
Animania HD
HD Cinema 10
Yeah, HD Cinema 10 is 10 channels rounding out the list to 21, but 10 channels of what? 10 channels of 10 movies in total, it seems -- and that wouldn't even fill a single channel over 24 hours without repeats. Let's look at the schedule today: here's when the movies that are showing were made: 1984, 1988, 1984, 1980, 1973. 1975, 1964, 1953. 1973, and 1970.
A whole 10 movies, the newest of which is 16 years old.
What about the other "exclusive" channels? From the names you can't even tell what some of them are even about!
East and West coast feeds... OK, when you've got nothing else to fill the bandwidth with, but it's not like that brings us any new content... just more not-even-24-hours-a-day-of-HD repeats.
The only thing many of these existing-but-not-widely-carried HD channels are doing is staking out claim to bandwidth on carriers. Hoping they'll get picked up and not leave room for their competitors, because it's a whole lot harder to take a channel away once you're carrying it than it is to just not carry it at all yet.
I think DirecTV is playing it smart -- waiting to see what channels come about that actually have some new, varied content that would be noticable to people and something people actually would want to watch. Something that supplements their current offerings, not just is another variation on the same old stuff.
__________________