Ok, final decision....I promise.
Do we want to do H2H - Points:
H2H Points is very similar to how Fantasy Football is played. It allows you to assign a given point value to individual stat categories (ie. HR=4, RBI=1, etc.) and each matchup's winner is determined solely by which team accumulates the most fantasy points.
OR H2H Each Category
H2H: Each Category is the most common type of head-to-head play in Fantasy Baseball. In head-to-head matchups, teams compete in each of the league's stat categories, earning a win, loss, or tie in every one.
OR H2H Most Categories
H2H Most Categories allows you to select a number of stat categories. For each matchup (usually Monday through Sunday) team totals are accumulated in each of the categories. At the end of the matchup, the winner is determined by which team wins the greater number of categories. The end result is a win (1-0-0), loss (0-1-0) or tie (0-0-1) for each team.
I've played all three in the past, and prefer either Points or Each Category.