Hi - just found this thread - interesting to know that I'm in good company. I had Dish Network for about 15 years, and really loved the Dish DVR (VIP 722). There are only two of us in the house, but we like to have the TV on in different room, so I was feeding the Dish box signal to all the TVs via coax for two old sets, and Component cables for three HD sets - with an HDMI connection in the living room. With the IR remote in the living room, and RF remotes elsewhere in the house, the hardware setup worked great - but at some point I realized that most of what we were watching was on local stations, and we only watched a couple of cable channels with any regularity - and we were just kind of "defaulting" to those channels - not really in love with most of the programs. We have good OTA reception (suburban Pittsburgh) of all the major networks - and a nice selection of independent and sub-channels, so I started toying with the idea of ditching cable and going with OTA - and saving $70+ per month. My biggest hesitation was losing the Dish DVR and a hardware setup that worked well for our needs. I considered ALL the options (HomeWorx, Tablo, Channel Master DVR+, etc.) and I ended up deciding that the Tivo Premier (which has both HDMI & Component output) would come the closest to duplicating the hardware setup and overall viewing experience I had with Dish. So, I bought a used Premiere with Lifetime ($300), upgraded it to a 3TB harddrive ($120), and added the RF Slide Pro Remote (with RF dongle), and another RF Roamio remote ($95). It's a pretty big upfront investment, but I should have it paid off in 8-months or less, and after that, it's money in my pocket.
I think the Tivo remote layout is not quite as intuitive as the Dish remote - but I'm getting used to it. I haven't made much use yet of the online offerings, but it's nice to know that the options are there. (I might spend the money for a Netflix subscription - still deciding.) The thing that has surprised me the most are the Tivo suggestions. I may reach a point where I decide to turn this off - I know most people do. But right now, it's managing to find and record a lot of OTA programming that I didn't even know existed. Sure it gets a lot of stuff I'm not interested in, but is has also found some real gems that have been fun to watch - including a few that have been added to my Season Pass list. With Dish, the cable channels were my default "go to" when I was bored and nothing else was on. At least for now, the Tivo suggestion list is filling that void.