I can only speak for myself, but the Red Sox record had NOTHING to do with my disdain for Manny last July.
The Sox could have been the '27 Yankees reincarnated or clones of the 1988 Orioles, it didn't matter to me.
What DID matter was Manny pushing down a 64 year old traveling secretary, refusing to pinch hit in a big game, flopping around the field in Anaheim laughing, taking three straight pitches right down the pike in a pinch hitting role against Mo Rivera, slapping a teammate in the dugout, etc., etc., etc.
I was on record here last July, saying I DID'NT CARE if the Red Sox finished in LAST PLACE. Just get this bum out of town. This is not revisionist history.
You can speak for me also, Bill. That was what settled it for me also.