As of now that is only on the newer 522 receiver. If you don't keep it hooked up to a phone line it is subject to the 4.99 additional receiver fee.
Now if they want to do this on all receivers I haven't heard. This would be bad for Dish if they go that far. We already have dvr fees on all newer dvr receivers and additional receiver fees for all receivers over the main unit, and now if they were to go with additional fees on top of all this for not connecting to a phone line, then that is going to be to much. Just to watch their service you could have additional fees in excess of 39.92 just for 4 receivers, in they were the older dvr receivers. The fees would be 59.98 if they were the newer dvrs and you didn't sub to AEP. That's all much as the programming itself.
This would be the ultimate in non friendly customer practices and for all the customers with no land line service would be the reason why they would definately churn. Dish and Directv will have to come up with some kind of geo sychronis tracking chip that will tell where the sat receiver is at all times in order to prevent stacking in the future.
The phone line connection is going the way of the dinasour. Even cable companies are getting in to phone line service for their cable and internet subs. Dish and Directv will have to come up with technological advances in tracking devices that do not involve more fees.
One of the advantages of Satellite over cable was originally a lack of fees for satellite. Now Dish is adding all kinds of fees that never existed before.
You can see that Dish isn't doing as well as before on the stock market. Directv is actually adding more subs then Dish for the first time in the last couple of years.
All these new fees and phone line connection practices are just pushing people to drop Dish and go with the competition. Dish , for the last couple of years, had been a customer friendly company that didn't care about the phone lines and gave you free dvr service .
Something has really changed in the last year and not for the better. Dish and Charlie Ergan has lost their direction. I hope this changes next year before Rupert buys Directv and changes everything or we might see Dish up for sale soon at this rate.