I'd agree with you if this was still 2006-2007 when there were only a handful of HD channels. Now that pretty much everything is in HD, I'd happily pay the $10 fee and be even more happy if they got rid of the fee and made HD the standard. Heck, a good chunk of the channels are HD standard only now meaning if you have the SD version, you're watching in letterbox and that looks really bad on a HDTV.count me as one of those who has sd only equipment. HD is nice, especially for sports, but i just don't think it's good enough to warrant having to pay $10 more a month.
Now if directv wants to upgrade all my sd recievers, install a new dish all for free and waive the $10 a month fee. then sign me up