It probably means that you need to be using
www.dishpointer.com and ignoring your other sources.
Dishpointer (given Solomons as a location) says that you need to set the EA dish to 85.3 degrees on the skew scale. I can't explain what is going on with the "satellite finder" other than you're probably misusing it.
As always, the secret to success comes in three steps:
1. Make sure the mast is plumb. Failure to do so will throw everything off in three dimensions (not impossible, but damned hard).
2. Set the elevation and skew on the dish scales and tighten down the locking nuts.
3. Swing the dish in the general direction until you land on a good signal.
If you've set the elevation and skew carefully, you shouldn't need to tinker with them.
Self-installing is overrated.