with a dish; it is size, then aiming; then the lnbf does its stuff. Noise level of the lnbf; gain in amplification; size of aperture or designed freq. range or signal desired might be the "actions" the lnbf can be rated for; all by itself from any "one dish". Right now my 1200 receiver is on MPEG-II; using dmx721; and is working at 52-3 quality; but not when it goes to 46 quality. How well I tune a feedhorn into the dish (and its size) it works on makes the only differences old lnbf or new. AND IF C ONLY LNBF; this does matter is the design! These C/Ku are a cause for both; and each; but not one or the other; so the probes or real antenna become the matter of the design that is focal length required for each to receive the optimum signal for each is a point the new design has under an older one. The Ku in the back of the throat requires that the installation point the feedhorn so that the ku is received without the c band probes getting in the way of the ku satellites aim! And be at the correct position to receive the focused ku signal. This makes the installer adjust for ku using a slight offset of c band focus; rolling the ku band into the feedhorn un-obstructed. The C band remains strong also; because the feedhorn (lnbf) has been optomized at KU (and then C Band is rolled into also); making this new style, or type, work as good as any other. Drift, noise, aperture alignment; all for the dish you need to tune; it is not "easy"; but it is optimal!!! The installer then can do it perfectly; or one or the other will lose a little bit of gain; very important at mpeg-iv; let alone 20 channel wonders.
Have you looked at a Co-rotor II+ lately? It is the opposite in design; in that it focuses ku first; while still not getting in the way of the C...No shadows occured on C because ku was focused before the c was realized; allowing the c band signals to go right by the ku. on a dmx741 the ku is way back in the feedhorn, after the c probe and bar caker! The bar at the opposite polarity is thick, and if you point the c band feedhorn at the middle of the dish like it is supposed to be; perfectly; the ku band probe will be partially blocked; but if you offset from the middle the lnbf pointing; the shadow is removed!
A feed with the c Band probes as more forward (bar and probe); would remove some of the shadow. At Ku frequency (a smaller aperture) is needed, but less shadow means smaller obstructions cause more losses.