As a early tester for DIRECTV stuff I had three Genie's in my house before getting the HS17. So far I've removed two of them and I'm close to getting rid of the third at last and go with just the HS17 and clients. Can the HS17 die, yep, and I worried enough to say I wouldn't go with it as the only STB, no. Past experience has been if a STB failed that DIRECTV had another one shipped out in a day or two for an exchange. In the mean time I can receive a bunch of channels via OTA and have Netflix and Amazon Prime for viewing and could do a free trial sign up for Hulu if needed.