Tvropro didn't and thats probally one of the reasons he hates it so much. Or he was afraid he might of liked it better than H2H! I don't know!
If you read my post here and others. It tells you I'm not impressed by the HD lite picture Direct or Dish puts out. And lets not forget ka band for HD, 3 times more the rain fade problem then ku, which is bad enough. Not to mention Mpeg 4 8PSK modulation which is harder to get in the first place, rain fade has to be insane. Too many negatives with U.S. pizza. They really did there homework on how to stretch the rubberband with total disregard of the end product and reception. They don't get it... Remove picture component and it can't be recreated. Then use practically no error correction since the transponders are so overfull to cram more garbage in that space. That plays well with path loss from rain fade on k band.
The only thing they have going for it is a few basic cable channels over c band. I ask myself are 2 channels that I watch mostly on Direct worth all this? Then one the programming is going to hell this year. The Canadian versions of these channels have more of the shows I want to watch I noticed. Plus Shaw looks better and better and its 19510 with 3/4 fec Dc 2 non down rez video, same as Hits. Much better picture than Direct and holds up much better in the rain because of the error correction.