the cup is half ... what?
Absolutely. Iceberg, the fact that you're getting DVB-S2 on a 30" dish is cause for hope regarding the next generation of satellite reception. I was afraid I'd have to go larger with my dishes once S2 becomes more common, but this proves there's not necessarily a correlation between S2 and a need for a larger dish.
What I think it proves, is that on a clear channel, you can do pretty much anything.
But, as the rest of this thread demonstrates, if you have adjacent-satellite interference messing with your bit-error-rate, then that big dish helps a lot!
You don't need more signal, you just need a clean signal, absent all that interference.
Look at Whitesprings on 129. It has an FEC of 1/2!
That means one out of two bits is error-correction code.
The receivers of today can pull that station out of the worst possible, weak, and noisy environment.
If the broadcasters operated S2 at an FEC of 1/2, I'm sure we'd be seeing folks picking it up on 18 and 20 inch dishes, too!
But no! They choose to operate it at FEC rates that offer even LESS error correction than ever!
And what dish size are they using at down-link sites? Eight foot?...?...
So, if today someone gets S2 on a 30" dish, that's a lot like getting Whitesprings on a 20.
It's the exception. Don't assume it's going to be the rule.
The unappetizing thing this thread shows, is that while today we can recommend 36" dishes to newbies for reliable reception, tomorrow that may become 48".