about receiving Circular on a Linear setup, i want to point out that yes, many circular transponders will be receivable at the cost of a small power loss, but only if they don't interfere with signal on the opposite polarity
For example if there's a transponder on 3840 L that is 20MHz wide, and nothing on Right-hand polarization between 3830 and 3850, it should be fine on a linear LNBF. But if there's something in that range on the Right-hand polarity, they will get mixed up in the linear feed, and usually will result in no reception.
On 47.5W we can get good reception with a linear feed, but on 40.5W, only a limited number of channels will be received with a linear feed compared to what is available with a circular feed.
The same is true on the DBS (Dish Network and Bell) satellites that use circular, most transponders overlap between L and R and with a linear LNBF we usually get nothing or just a few of them, compared to what we can get with a circular feed.
For example if there's a transponder on 3840 L that is 20MHz wide, and nothing on Right-hand polarization between 3830 and 3850, it should be fine on a linear LNBF. But if there's something in that range on the Right-hand polarity, they will get mixed up in the linear feed, and usually will result in no reception.
On 47.5W we can get good reception with a linear feed, but on 40.5W, only a limited number of channels will be received with a linear feed compared to what is available with a circular feed.
The same is true on the DBS (Dish Network and Bell) satellites that use circular, most transponders overlap between L and R and with a linear LNBF we usually get nothing or just a few of them, compared to what we can get with a circular feed.