As I recall, Dish wanted to carry Yes. The folks at Yes wanted their channel to be broadcast over the entire Dish population at the base level. That way Yes could get paid for every subscriber that Dish had and it had to be at the base level. Dish wanted to put Yes in the Sports tier so that subs who cared would pay for that privilege, just like Pac 12, and a host of others, is set up today. Yes wouldn't bend so Dish didn't either.