That's funny you brought this subject up Sabres, because Mike and Mike were talking about this very subject on their radio show this morning!
They said that Buster Olney considered the Tigers/Marlins trade of Dontrelle Willis and Miguel Cabrera for a package of 6 prospects quite possibly the worst trade ever! At the time, this was considered a huge trade that would put the Tigers in position to be one of the favorites to contend for a World Series.
Just last month, Cabrera signed an eight-year, $153.3 million contract extension. Cabrera is batting .278 with 8 home runs so far with the Tigers. A far cry from the .320, .339 and .323 batting average and 34, 26 and 33 home runs in which he had for the Marlins the previous 3 years. Considering Cabrera's now one of the richest guys in baseball, I would think a lot more is expected of him.
Willis is signed through 2010 and will earn between $29-$30 million. Willis never had any resemblance of success so far with the Tigers. He's pitched in 4 games for the Tigers this year and walked 21 batters in 11 1/3 innings, while compiling a lofty 10.32 ERA. To his defense, the bad start may partially be due to his stint on the DL, but this lack of production recently got Willis sent down to the Minors. Detroit's single A affiliate to be exact!
We will find out more in the future (obviously) as to which team benefited or got hurt more. But in shear money spent and performance in return, at this point, I may actually have to agree with Olney.
Carl Pavano - NYY
4 year, $37M contract with only 19 games started and 5 wins.
Danny Darwin and Matt (I can't even throw to first base) Young.
This won't seem big now because of the different scale of salaries, but when free agency first started in baseball, the Indians' signing of Wayne Garland in 1977 turned out to be the first huge bust signing in free agent history. The perennial bottom-feeders were trying to make a big splash, but it backfired.
From Wikipedia:
"Garland's best season came in 1976 when he posted a won-loss record of 20-7 [with Baltimore]. He signed a 10-year, $2.3 million contract with the Indians as a free agent prior to the 1977 season (which was the first season of large-scale free agency in Major League Baseball). However, he failed to reach the heights of his 1976 season, going on to record a 28-48 win-loss record with Cleveland, being waived five years into the deal after the 1981 season. He later served as a minor league manager."
Wow. Theres such a huge pool to choose from....
I'm not sure about the exact $$$ and years on these, but:
Barry Zito with the Giants
Jason Giambi with the Yankees
....to name a few
Ryan Leaf - $16 million signing bonus with the Chargers. Total bust.
I dont even know where to find the terms but Im going with Vinny Baker and Pervis Ellison.
"Not in Service" Pervis may still be collecting.
I think the Celtics are still paying Michael Oliwakandi, also.
HOW IN THE WORLD did he get drafted ahead of Pierce, Dirk, Jamison, and Vince Carter?
Good question, he gives the word stiff new meaning!
You could help me out when I put up my "NBA Draft Busts" thread after the NBA Finals are over...
During the early days of free agency there was a second baseman named Rennie Stennett that was awarded a million dollar plus contract with the Giants and in two seasons and 158 games proceeded to hit .240. This after having a pretty good career with a lifetime .280 avg. Not ever mistaken as a slick fielder, Stennnett kicked the ball around at SS making 15 errors in about 100 games.This should make for some lively debate.
What are the worst contracts in sports history you can recall?
Here are the criteria I'm looking for:
-Splashy signing
-Big bucks
-Team doesn' do well/underachieves
-Player doesn't perform well
Alex Rodriguez's 10 year, 252 million deal with Texas won't count- he didn't exactly hit below the Mendoza Line with the Rangers...
Mike Hampton with anybody....If somebody farts within 100 miles of this guy , he ends up on the DL..Wow. Theres such a huge pool to choose from....
I'm not sure about the exact $$$ and years on these, but:
Barry Zito with the Giants
Mike Hampton with the Rockies
Darren Dreifort with the Dodgers
Jason Giambi with the Yankees
....to name a few