Good Question...not easy for me to answer.
That's a great question, but you need to add several more options. Personally speaking, VOOM needs to work on their pricing model in order to stay competitive with Cable and other DBS providers. Although we could afford to pay a lot more for our home entertainment expense (and Internet), there is only so much we are willing to pay to watch TV; it's a personal choice and each person/family will make this decisions with their head, heart and ultimately their wallet. I'm sure many VOOMers are faced with a similar issues and decisions, so I'm just going to lay them out here for your consideration.
My Issues:
- I love HD and prefer not to watch SD
- VOOM is my first and only DBS provider
- I have little interested in D* or E* unless they dramatically increase HD offerings
- I have 2 OTA antennas and a ready spare
- Reliably receive programming from 2 DMAs and unreliably from 2 others
- Most our our "planned watching" is spend watching OTA Prime Time or Sports
- I hate Cable, but they offer an affordable HD DVR - taking advantage of 6 month promo
- We gotta have Broadband Internet - Cable offers significant bundled discounts
- Stand Alone broadband $54.95, is only $27.05 when bundled with Cable - no DSL in area
- I will not maintain both Cable and VOOM in 2005 - paying for duplicate SD channels
- I am not going to pay VOOM $199 to install 2 additional STBs and/or thin clients...it ain't gonna happen.
- Prefer if VOOM would mail the equipment and cable and will handle the rest, but I am not going to pay $199
My choices:
1. Get Va Va VOOM at the "expected" 2005 price
2. Get Va Va VOOM at the "hopeful" 2005 adjusted price
3. Get Premium Cable package and drop VOOM.
4. Get rid of VOOM and Cable and go OTA all the way.
Assumption: Although we don't need Va Va VOOM (1 or 2 premium channels would suffice), it makes more sense since DBS and Cable offer significant package discounts. Therefore, my price comparison will be between the upper-tier packages.
Cable HD:
$113.45 Ultimate - 4 premiums, all the digital cable garbage, plus Broadband Internet (discount breaks down to $27.05 per month)
$7.95 HD DVR Rental
$4.95 DVR Service
$1.75 Cable Card for 2nd HDTV
$0.00 N/A for 3rd set
$5.00 HD Tier
$133.10 (total) which includes 14 HD channels, HD DVR and Broadband Internet
VOOM (Current 2005 Pricing Model - DVR Rental/Fee is an estimate):
VaVa VOOM $89.99
HD DVR Rental $9.50
DVR Service $5.00
2nd STB $14.50
3rd STB $14.50
$133.49 (total for VOOM)
$54.95 (Stand alone Internet via Adelphia monopoly - no DSL in area)
$188.44 (total for VOOMs 40 HD channels and Broadband Internet)
VOOM (Hopeful 2005 Pricing Model - DVR Rental/Fee is an estimate):
VaVa VOOM $89.99
HD DVR Rental $9.50
DVR Service $5.00
2nd STB (mirror) $5.00 *free STB rental (up to 3) with 1 year subscription to VaVa VOOM
3rd STB (mirror) $5.00 *free Installation with 1 year subscription to VaVa VOOM
$114.49
$54.95 (Stand alone Broadband Internet)
$169.44
Common Channels between Cable HD and VOOM: (East and West Coast feeds are redundant and unnecessary with a DVR):
ABC-HD
CBS-HD
FOX-HD
NBC-HD
HBO-HD
SHO-HD
CINEMAX-HD
STARZ-HD
ESPN-HD
DISC-HD
HD Channels Unique to Cable HD:
HDNET
HDN MOVIES
INHD1
INHD2
HD Channels Unique to VOOM:
21 VOOM HD Exclusives (would miss to an unknown degree)
TMC-HD (don't subscribe)
ENCORE-HD (will miss, but I subscriptions to HBO and Cinemax should negate)
BRAVO-HD (won't miss at all)
TNT-HD (may miss a few things, but this will be picked up by Cable shortly)
PLAYBOY-HD (don't subscribe)
As you can see from the above, selecting VOOM over Cable would basically give me the VOOM Exclusives for $55 more per month (2005 pricing model) or $36 (my wishful pricing model). Offhand, the VOOM Exclusives are not worth it since I already have more than enough programming to watch. Like I said, I love VOOM and actually get a fair amount of use out of the Exclusives, but still most of our HD programming is via OTA and Cable does a much better job of pricing...there is only so much I am willing to pay for TV and there is only so much time I have to watch. I don't know what I am going to do in 2005, but I can honestly say that VOOM needs to look at their pricing model. Perhaps I would be willing to subscribe to VOOM as an add-on service without the SD channels.
Comments?