IMHO,
The ESPNs in a box:
- Sports argument shows, the first two or three of which were OK (PTI, Sports Reporters, etc) but they have gone to the well vastly too many times. You can only argue about the same stuff so much.
- SportsCenter. Which long ago stopped being a sports version of the nightly news and is now full of all sorts of ho-ha.
(And both of the above VASTLY give too much coverage to the NBA relative to its relative popularity. If you took a stopwatch and added up the seconds spent on the NBA and divided it by the NBA's actual ratings, the resulting number would be 1000s of times higher than any other sport. And both of the above ignore any sport (except those too big to ignore, such as the Super Bowl or NCAA Finals) that is not on ESPN.)
- Self-righteous self-appointed arbiters of racial / social / political / ethics of anything slightly sports related. A trend that seems to be expanding with recent hires/rehires of more retreaded political chattering class castoffs.
- Pre and post game shows which are about the only watchable non-event thing left on the channel.
- Actual live events, which are not really any better or worse on ESPN relative to being on any other channel.
IF FS1 plays its sports news shows straight and "fair and balanced" (in terms of what it covers, not wanting to argue politics here) and develops a few good pre- and post- and sports specific shows, and develops some other shows like PTI, it can blow ESPN away.
BTW, re the AFL discussion above, AFL and rugby are transitioning to FS2, as Fox Soccer is shutting down in two weeks.