I voted that CableVision will keep them. Why? If you haven't noticed...other than the broadcast networks, INHDs, HDNets and a few premium movie channels, there really isn't all that many HD channels comparatively speaking. Also, if you haven't noticed...Cable TV has taken the offensive by offering more than double the HD programming of D* and E* along with inexpensive HD DVR rentals. Also, if you haven't noticed...VOOM has a lot of its own HD content (VOOM's 21 Exclusives) as well as the possibility of starting WE-HD, IFC-HD and AMC-HD.
However you may feel about some of VOOM's less-than-stellar HD classics (i.e. Grass Growing HD), you cannot deny they have a handful of keepers like MonstersHD, RaveHD, RushHD, WorldSportHD, Animania, Gallery, Auction (yes, there is a market for the last two, even if they are only filler channels for an HD package). Cable is moving quickly toward HD and would love nothing more than to offer HD context well ahead of E* and D* who current don't have the capacity. They could offer something like this 7 channel package and net $4 per sub x 1 million subs = $48M per year. As D* and E* and Cable come up to speed, it's possible for VOOM to be pulling-in $100-$200 million per year in HD programming fees by selling some of their programming.
Better yet, why not license the HD package mentioned above and bundle it with WE, AMC, and IFC for an extra $1 a month. They now have a potential market of 75 million viewers. The Cable providers would be happy because they would be able to offer plenty of cheap HD programming well ahead of D* or E*, CableVision would be happy because they will now be raking in money and mass marketing their HD programming...all the while treating D* and E* to some Deliverance Style Ned Beatty treatment. :shocked
Selling a subset of their programming could surely be profitable and help subsidize VOOM while they develop and expand their base - just look at the money makers that are WE, AMC and IFC. As time goes by HD will be old-hat and mass market share will keep the VOOM HD channels alive and well...especially if they are strategically and affordable packaged as I mentioned above. If the VOOM Satellite service fails then so be it...however, VOOM is currently doing some very good things with their programming, it will only continue to improve, and they do have a track record of providing successful programming services.
Anyway, Wilt just drop-shipped two new receivers to a local installer. The installer will be out Friday morning to install my new receivers and reinstall my old one. I will be VA VA VOOMING soon. Sorry, but no DOOM & GLOOM in my home!