I took an even closer look at DirecTV today. Their pricing is intentionally confusing, but I think I managed to decypher it.
I'm not including their discounts because if I switch, it will be long term.
I have pretty much everything with DISH right now- $120 a month. Same thing on DirecTV- $126. However, I don't watch sports, except Hockey. If I drop the sports pack, it's DISH-$120, DirecTV- $121
If I drop Cinemax, it's DISH- $110, DirecTV- $113
If I drop The HD Extras/Ultimate, it's DISH $100, DirecTV $108.
The more I drop, the more expensive DirecTV gets! I guess DISH is cheaper at the bottom, and Direct has better pricing on premiums.
I would still consider switching...Direct has several more HD Premiums, and that's what's important to me. However DISH has MORE Cinemax HD channels now, and has always led DirecTV in the SD premiums. There are a few Showtime/TMC HD channels already uplinked, and 15 newly empty slots. DISH could catch up on HD premiums tomorrow if they really wanted to.
I guess I'll wait until September at least. If Direct jumps WAY ahead then, maybe I'll consider switching. DISH has the bandwidth to do a lot of catching up before then.
I did the Direct/Dish Comparison as well and found, to get similar level of programming (this includes international and Cinemax), I would pay $95 after rebates and $118 thereafter. I pay $75 with Dish. That's a $43/month diff after rebates expire! Am I alone in having such a large savings with Dish. I currently receive no rebates or any other incentives.