This does raise a good point about Dish subscribers who already had HBO and are getting it credited back on their bill, who are now paying for HBO from an alternative source, likely directly from AT&T. So now, when HBO returns (assuming for a second that it will return) that credit will end, and the subscriber will start being charged by Dish again. However, the subscriber has also already paid a non-refundable fee in advance for a month of streaming HBO, thus paying for the exact same content twice. So, who bears the responsibility for refunding the overcharge? Ideally, since both sides (Dish and AT&T) caused the dispute in the first place, both sides would take partial responsibility for refunding the double payment to the subscriber. However, the subscriber is probably not going to want the hassle of calling both companies to get a refund. So perhaps, as a measure of good will to existing subscribers who have been patient, and in order to avoid the situation described above, Dish should give all existing HBO subscribers a free month of HBO when it returns. This would give these subscribers time to use up the streaming subscription that has already been paid for, and then cancel it before any charge for HBO appears on their Dish bill. Otherwise, their only other alternative would be to immediately cancel their Dish HBO subscription as soon as HBO returns, in order to avoid being overcharged. I would think that Dish would want to avoid that latter scenario, as it would defeat the purpose of bringing HBO back to Dish in the first place.