They have always offered lifetime. The Roamio OTA was the only exception of no lifetime on the unit unless you had purchased a unit that had lifetime on it (that started last May or so....). The previous monthly units they wouldnt allow it. So I upgraded to a Basic Roamio and they threw lifetime on it
(already had a S3 with Lifetime on it)
Right. (and this is more for Bob) And the Mini was also originally monthly only, but then later sold them with "Lifetime" included, and, if you called to request it and willing to pay a one-time payment of $59 (about that price), extended the Lifetime to those who were paying monthly for the Mini. So, those people were really P.O.ed because everyone else got a Mini for the original or later reduced price with Lifetime. TiVo granted no credit for all those several months, some for years, towards the one-time fee. Not beating up on TiVo, just sharing the facts.
Bob, if you don't have your S3 with PLS, then TiVo may offer you an upgrade, at hundreds of dollars, to the Bolt. The Bolt comes with first year free, but monthly ($14.99 or $19.99) or annual ($149.99) after that. Further, TiVo's new Liftetime now re-named "All-in" option is $599 with no MSD. If TiVo gives you a discount on the box, you may have to pay FULL rates for any of the monthly, annual, or All-in options.
I think Bob is in for a shock when he gets up to speed on TiVo as of today. I would like to see TiVo around for many years, but business is business. I understand TiVo is under pressure to survive, but while the new pricing looks good on the spreadsheet, it will only accelerate TiVo's demise, IMHO.
Of course, this is not to absolve Dish, DirecTV, nor the cable companies for its notorious fee structures.