I did pay $49, but the credit in the letter was for $99. I too only want or like the HD portion of Superfan but I still can't understand what the crying is all about. So we got it free last year. How anyone thinks that receiving something free one year entitles them to it for life amazes me. So $49 above and beyond the ST price, whatever it is to watch my out of market team {Eagles} when they are not National is soooo worth it. Now this credit too, and lets face it most of us got great deals on our new HD Tivos, rebates, discounts, free programming etc...sounds like a lot of whining to me. Yes we want better, yes we want more and yes we want it all for nothing, but we live in the real world remember. Besides some issues with PQ which I still have faith that D* will resolve I really don't see what everyone is screaming about. If your team is local, then hey you don't neet the SF anyway for those of us that have moved from our favorites, it doesn't get any better than this. Suppose when MLB games are available in HD you will all protest and strike also.