Fair thought. However, even major broadcast net shows have changed networks. Just as an example, Medium, (didn't Scrubs change nets?) and a few others have. Also, major net shows, such as The Apprentice, premiere on the NBC TV Network, but the premier episode is replayed on a channel that NBC owns, such as Bravo or MSNBC, so using a DishPass provide protection if a show is not recorded due to priority.
However, it really is to each his own. We DishPasser prefer to get FULL VALUE for our monthly bill and do have a rich knowledge and appreciation for a number of musicians and other performers reflecting wide variety of interests and entertainment. But if one just wants to record Dancing with the Stars, American Idol, and a few other shows, and has no interest beyond that, then DishPass could certainly be useless to that person. I'm sure a lot of non-power users find it useless as would a lot of senior citizens because often those folks just want to record only a very few shows and it would not be right to force people to use DishPass if they don't want to. But, the result is, people are missing out, but if one doesn't know what they have missed, then no "doooh!" moments about having missed something.
Oh Jesus... seriously? I think that's a bit of a stretch.
I for one don't use DishPass because I don't want my reciever filling up with programming that I have no intention of watching. Same reason why I never found Tivo's thumbs up/down feature appealing. (But to each his own, there are people that I'm sure swear by it too.) I want my receiver to record the shows I want and that's it. And just because I'm really into TV and movies, there's hardly ever an occasion when I don't know that a show I want to see is starting and where to find it. If I really thought about it, maybe there's something I could use a DishPass for but in the many years I had a 622, a situation has never come up. Does it mean that I feel that I'm not getting my $6 (and now $10 as MikeD just CAN'T help himself from pointing out to everyone every single day) worth? Nope. I have plenty to watch now, and stuff saved to a EHD to keep for later.