Specific antenna question for Detroit area locals

Toggle sidebar
S

satnewb

SatelliteGuys Pro
Original poster
Pub Member / Supporter
Mar 9, 2011
1,466
681
New Baltimore, MI
I know there's a few of us on here. Currently I have a diginova boss on the garage roof. No complaints except for Fox2. It's always been an issue dating back to the days I was installing these things for Dish. I would say 75 % of the time it's fine, and the rest of the time it's not. I can go on the roof every 6 months and get slight improvements but I'm never above a 55-60 signal strength at the closest tv to the antenna, which is about 50 feet of cable away. I'm about another 60 feet to an amplifier in the basement and then it splits 5 ways to TV's in my house, and through an underground burial cable to several more next door at my neighbor's.

I realize this is a non-standard installation, but it's been working reasonably well for several years, except when it doesn't. I'm confident if I had a better antenna for vhf I would be able to eliminate most of my issues. It's difficult to find any vhf specific reviews on Amazon so I figured I'd ask here.

What antenna are you folks using that is pulling in the vhf frequency for Fox2 reliably. I'm in 48047 zip code and the antenna is mounted probably 16 feet up.

Thanks in advance guys.
 
Last edited:
Looked at a rabbitears report, I would go with a mid size combination VHF high/UHF antenna such as the Winegard HD7694P. Your Televes has no VHF gain. You could also probably get by with a smaller combo such as the RCA 751 or similar, which has a wider receive beamwidth.
 
  • Like
Reactions: satnewb
  • Like
Reactions: satnewb and FTA4PA
For the OP, just remember that while the Newark VHF High Yagi's are good antennas, and one of, if not the only VHF High only Yagis out there, they will not pick up your UHF signals. You would need 2 antennas.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: satnewb
Thanks for the replies everyone. Gonna go ahead and try the Winegard mentioned above. Don't really wanna have to deal with 2 separate antennas and a combiner.
 
Will update with results when it's installed. My neighbors are in Florida until May. As far as I can recall he has 6 TV's in addition to my 2 tuner tablo and additional 5 TV's. So 12 separate feeds.
 
primestar31 said:
Here's one that will work for Fox2, which is RF7: https://www.newark.com/stellar-labs/30-2476/deep-fringe-directional-antenna/dp/71Y5462 Best anteena I have owened!


Here's the slightly smaller version:


Get the larger one, if you are really splitting it as much as you say. It has twice the gain as the smaller one. Either are great antenna's for VHF-high.

IF you can't see the links I posted, disable your ad blocker, and hit REFRESH
Click to expand...
 
Comptech said:
Wrong, works great on UHF also.
Click to expand...
satnewb said:
Well now I'm confused...
Click to expand...
The VHF Yagis are not designed to receive UHF signals. Yes, they will probably get you OK reception on UHF, some of the time, on some of the stations, but the receive pattern is likely to be unpredictable. The better option is going to be sticking with an inband antenna designed for VHF high and UHF. Since you are receiving VHF 7 sort of OK now most of the time, you do not need a great deal more gain on VHF, the 2475 and 2476 are almost overkill. You can kill both birds with one stone using the Winegard. I would worry about not picking up some of the weaker UHF stations if using a VHF high Yagi.
 
Trust me, I get 30 plus UHF stations here, coming of the side of it, Throw your antenna handbooks away. You need longer elements For VHF, granted. But the shorter wavelenth UHF still comes into the antenna. Now would a UHF be better? Yes, but not much with this one.
 
Comptech said:
Throw your antenna handbooks away. You need longer elements For VHF, granted. But the shorter wavelenth UHF still comes into the antenna.
Click to expand...

Using a VHF antenna on UHF is unpredictable. Yes, it will pick up some signals, but the VHF antenna will have no UHF directivity. The lack of gain in the forward direction will reduce the strength of the UHF signals and pick up reflections coming from all directions.

I would consider an ANT 751 before attempting UHF reception on a VHF antenna.

Note that Solid Signal, an antenna specialty store in Novi, MI, is close to the poster.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 907TECH
Amazon delivered the Winegard today. Had it installed and up and running within an hour. I'm seeing about a 30 point gain in signal strength on vhf.

Thanks everyone.
 
  • Like
Reactions: primestar31
Amazon delivered the Winegard today. Had it installed and up and running within an hour. I'm seeing about a 30 point gain in signal strength on vhf.
Thanks everyone.
[/QUOTE]
You are welcome! Hope the beamwidth is good enough to gather the perimeter stations OK... How are all your UHF coming in?
 
It comes in pixellated in the garage. No signal anywhere else. Really all I care about are the big 4 and pbs so it's not an issue.
 
I am betting you have a Winegard HD7694P. I am aiming mine at Southfield from 25 miles away. It is indoors and works great on getting virtual channels 2, 4, 7, 20, 50, 56 and 62. When WPXD gets back to full power, I should have virtual 31 as well.
 
Yeah 7694P. I believe it pulled in 59 channels when I ran the scan. Channel 18 has like 5 sub-channels, Channel 14 has 12, plus Channel 31/38 etc.
 
E

I see that TiVo Edge for Antenna is discontinued (even the 2 tuner now), are they going to make another OTA DVR or is TiVo done?

  • edisonprime
  • Replies: 4
Hyper Casey

WJRT ABC 12 Mid-Michigan TheGrio issue and adding THIS TV

  • Hyper Casey
  • Replies: 1

Similar threads

T
New Construction Attic Antenna Concerns
Replies
18
Views
851
navychop
navychop
primestar31
WAQP-49 RF36 Question for Trip
Replies
30
Views
2K
primestar31
primestar31
S
How to repair antenna wire
Replies
36
Views
2K
Starr
S
tcpuccio1
OTA antenna combiner
Replies
16
Views
2K
sktn77a
S
K
    • Like
antenna signal
Replies
5
Views
1K
c-spand
C

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 0, Members: 0, Guests: 0)

Who Read This Thread (Total Members: 50)

Share this page

Share this page
Top
Back