Maybe they don't want to take it back cause the aftermath of bursting it on the way home might be worse than if it burnt in open space.
All of the DirecTV satellites are in Geostationary Orbit, which is 22,236 Miles above the surface of the planet. This means NONE of these types of satellites are Capable of being brought back to the earth.If they are worried about this thing exploding why are they going to raise the orbit and keep it in space, which will then have more junk floating around vs. causing it to burn up in the atmosphere?