NY, Chicago and Atlanta are all DNS cities, yes they can change that but NY matches D* so it's not going anywhere. Also all of the cities you have mentioned are LARGE markets. Think about this for a moment, if you were E* would you require the largest number of subscribers, who have access to the most provider options, to add a second dish for locals just so a tiny fraction of your subscribers could have a couple more HD channels? I think not.
My big concern is that E* will follow D* lead and compress the crap out of any HD channels added before MPEG4. I invested a large sum of money to watch HD, NOT HD lite.
NightRyder