Where does he rank in wins? That really is the only number that concerns me. Enjoying your baseball season yet?
Ah, the ultimate debate between ERA and Wins.....
I'm just saying, the Wins Stat can often times be skewed. Cliff doesn't play defense and doesn't bat. He has no control over how many runs his team scores or whether his manager lets an uncoordinated First Baseman/DH play Right Field when he pitches.
For instance, which of the two would you consider the better pitcher this year? Tim Wakefield or Edwin Jackson?
On one had, you have a guy who leads the AL in wins with 11. He also happens to have a not too impressive ERA of 4.31. Did he turn some of those not-to-impressive outings into wins on the heels of the great run support provided by those intimidating bats in Boston?
The next subject we have is poor Edwin Jackson. This poor sap has threw for over 121 innings and still has a very impressive 2.52 ERA (nearly 2 points lower than Wakefield!), while compiling a ho-hum 7-4 record. He stuck out nearly 100 batters and has only walked 35. What if Edwin had the same run support as in Boston? I'll tell you what. He'd have more wins and the comparison between the two wouldn't even be close.