Ok, I used club dish card from one of the members here to sign up with Dish Network last month. I used Dish1up to sign up for my subscription. They said no problem with the card. Well, as it turns out, after many phone calls with Dish1up, they are now being told by DishNetwork, that I cannot qualify for the $50 credit using the card because I did not go through DishNetwork. The member here who gave me a number to use, he does not get his credit either. Apparently they are saying, that the cards are only good through Dish, and no other retailer. Forgive the dumb question, but are they right? Or are they just blowing smoke up my @ss to get rid of me?