PS...PlaySingular; HPMAN’s Review of the PS3

[JamesJ]

None and all.
It's the quality of the movie, in other words it has to have some value. It could be artistic value or anything else: being a provocative one or has a thought-provoking moral or even just represents completely new paradigm in movie making etc.

The aforementioned four movies sported zero values - in other words these are utterly worthless crap, regardless of the display resolution of their medium.

Listen t2k that is your opinion and that is really unfair to those who like those movies, your kinda getting carried away and really starting to tread on thin ice.....just because you dont like what someone else likes dosent mean its crap, or not thought provoking, I really wish you would change your way that you write as it does tick off alot of people.

 

[T2k]

T2k, the only one here that's high is you, man. I would like to know how you manage to find every positive post about Sony or the PS3 and bring your Doom & Gloom into the discussion.

I swear to God you ARE high, Joe - where did you read anything particular about PS3 from me here?

BTW -- Xmen on BluRay has recieved excellent reviews from every reviewer that has watched the title on BluRay. It must make you HD-DVD supporters nervious when BluRay titles start getting high marks. Of course having some reviewers of the PS3 state that it is an excellant BluRay DVD player isn't exactly what everyone wanted to hear either is it?

It's official: you ARE HIGH. Most likely some type of acid stuff.

Reason is simple: there's no other explanation for your hallucinogenic responses to never existed posts.

 

[BobMurdoch]

Until there is a "HD" DVD title out, that is both on HD DVD and BluRay....

The comparisons between the "Quality" of them is well... not 100% (for the lack of a better word)

Superman Returns hits both formats next week..... There's your A/B test for someone to perform...

 

[T2k]

When Criterion Collection decides which format to use then I'll buy an HD movie...

 

[tnsprin]

Until there is a "HD" DVD title out, that is both on HD DVD and BluRay....

The comparisons between the "Quality" of them is well... not 100% (for the lack of a better word)

Several titles are out in both formats. Not having both I can't compare, but at least one reviewer does so check out some of the comparisons.

 

[BobMurdoch]

I'd be interested in seeing sales for titles available on both formats, which should give a better idea of what format is gaining traction and market share.

Superman Returns is one of those titles. It hits stores Tuesday,... by next week, we'll see which format is doing better getting widely adopted, although the clearcut winner is still probably 12-18 months away..