I'm also not a fan of rotors. Unfortunately WSFA and WTVM are on adjacent channels 11 and 12. Jointennas don't work on adjacent channels. You can ignore NBC on 12 and watch WLTZ on 35 instead. Channel 11 is in the right direction without a rotor or joiner. A Winegard HD7694P will work for you. Don't go bigger!
You have two more VHF stations that you can get.
WACS channel 8
WABW channel 6
It's easy to add channel 6 with a HLSJ
It's cheap to add channel 8 with a Jointenna on Amazon.com.
Some of your antenna decisions would be based on how much you like PBS and which PBS stations carry identical programming.
These suggestions should be verified with an exact tvfool report.
Here is what I would like to do, maybe you can help.
I have two options.
Option 1:
WRBL - CBS - Columbus, GA
WTVM - ABC - Columbus, GA
WCOV - FOX - Montgomery, AL
WSFA - NBC - Montgomery, AL
That would get my my big four as the NBC and FOX out of Columbus, GA power is low and I have a hard time getting those.
Option 2:
WTVY - CBS - Dothan, AL
WDHN - ABC - Dothan, AL
WCOV - FOX - Montgomery, AL
WSFA - NBC - Montgomery, AL
That would also get the big four.
How can I get this to work?
Thanks for all your help